פסקי דין

(ת"א) 1702/07 תא (ת"א) 1702-07 אלי עזור נ' CanWest Global Communications Corp - חלק 24

20 יוני 2012
הדפסה

A. I, I try to take a particular element in terms of my drafting and that is if somebody want to take pride of authorship I will let them do that, I don’t find any particular need other than the substance?

Q. Nobody wants to take credit from you concerning this document.

A. So if he wanted to use a particular word I wasn’t going to go back and word smith it beyond the point of making the important components of the documents speak properly."

הסבר זה לפיו מדובר אך בניסוח שאין לו משמעות אין לקבל. כזכור, הנתבעים לא דחו מפורשות את תכנית המשחק וגרסתם הייתה כי אמרו למורל תקשורת ללכת בדרך המלך, ובכך דחו לכאורה את תכנית המשחק. הנתבעים הם שטענו כי הסכם שכר הטרחה הוא הרלבנטי, ועולה ממנו דחית תכנית המשחק. במצב דברים, זה כינוי מרקעי תקשורת כמטרה, מביא למסקנה ההפוכה. היינו,

--- סוף עמוד 24 ---

כי הייתה תכנית והייתה מטרה וכי הנתבעים היו שבעי רצון מהתכנית. לייפסיק נחקר בעניין זה, כדלקמן (עמ' 75 ש' 22 עד עמ' 76 ש' 7):

"Q. So apparently without hearing what you are saying to us now, that you rejected out of hand the game plan and having no e-mail or letter to Moti Morel to support that, my conclusion is that you got a game plan, you were content with that you signed a retainer fee with Moti Morel and among all those hundreds of letters and e-mails you cannot find any paper to refute that, am I correct to say that the only thing against that is what you are telling us right now?

A. If you look at the retainer letter it talks about a subsequent game plan being provided…"

ובהמשך (עמ' 77 ש' 8 עד עמ' 78 ש' 11):

"Q. Now, again, you got this a day after you got the game plan. Because it’s dated February 2 and this is February 3rd so, I guess the telephone conversation was somewhere in the middle.

A. Yes.

Q. And you get this second letter which is totally not detailed but saying something very general, so how do you think we can be convinced out of this letter that you rejected out of hand all the detail letter, it doesn’t say anything other than that. The detail letter contains also parts of this, it’s not saying in refer to this we are doing only this and not that or any other wording that suggest that you didn’t take the whole deal, the only thing that it says that you will get something else or as you go by you will get a … or?

עמוד הקודם1...2324
25...59עמוד הבא