פסקי דין

עא 6821/93 בנק המזרחי המאוחד בע"מ נ' מגדל כפר שיתופי, פ"ד מט(4) 221 - חלק 180

09 נובמבר 1995
הדפסה

DEAL WITH THE ISSUE AT ALL" (LA FOREST, "THE BALANCING OF INTERESTS UNDER

.(THE CHARTER" 2 N.J.C.L. 133, 143

לשם הגשמת משימה זו על בית המשפט ועל עורכי הדין הטוענים לפניו לפתח כישורים נוספים, המאפשרים להם להתמודד עם "העובדות החברתיות". עמד על כך השופט למר (LAMER), נשיא בית המשפט העליון של קנדה, בציינו כי המהפכה החוקתית בקנדה בתחום זכויות האדם חייבה התמודדות השופט ועורך הדין עם תשתית עובדתית מסוג חדש:

THESE DEVELOPMENTS REQUIRE LAWYERS AND JUDGES TO HAVE A WHOLE NEW RANGE" OF SKILLS. WE NEED TO BE ABLE TO LOOK INTELLIGENTLY AT QUESTIONS OF

SOCIAL POLICY, TO IDENTIFY THE SORTS OF EXPERTISE THAT THE PARTICULAR

PROBLEM REQUIRES, TO DEAL WITH MATERIAL FROM A WIDE RANGE OF DISCIPLINES

AND TO INTERACT EFFECTIVELY WITH PERSONS WHO POSSESS MANY SORTS OF

,EXPERTISE. IN ADDITION TO THE TRADITIONAL TECHNICAL SKILLS OF THE LAWYER

WE NEED A DEEP UNDERSTANDING OF THE MOST FUNDAMENTAL PRINCIPLES OF THE

LAW; AN UNDERSTANDING WHICH IS BROAD ENOUGH TO RELATE TO A WIDE VARIETY

OF OTHER DISCIPLINES" (A. LAMER, "CANADA'S LEGAL REVOLUTION: JUDGING IN

.(THE AGE OF THE CHARTER OF RIGHTS" 28 ISR. L. REV. (1994) 579, 581

 

--- סוף עמוד  440 ---

בהמשך דבריו מציין השופט למר, כי בתי המשפט בקנדה פיתחו טכניקות שיפוטיות לטיפול בעובדות החברתיות:

COURTS NOW ARE ROUTINELY RECEIVING A GOOD DEAL OF WHAT CAN BE..."

REFERRED TO AS SOCIAL FACT EVIDENCE. THIS SORT OF EVIDENCE IS OFTEN

DIRECTED TO THE QUESTIONS OF WHAT IS THE IMPACT OF LEGISLATION ON SOCIETY

AND WHAT WOULD BE THE IMPACT OF ALTERNATIVE WAYS OF CONFRONTING THE

SOCIAL PROBLEM. THIS KIND OF EVIDENCE IS LIKE THAT WHICH IS RELEVANT IN

PROCEEDINGS BEFORE A PARLIAMENTARY COMMITTEE WHEN PROPOSED LEGISLATION

IS BEING CONSIDERED. PARTICULARLY WHERE THE QUESTION IS WHETHER CERTAIN

LAWS ARE JUSTIFIED IN A FREE AND DEMOCRATIC SOCIETY, DEBATE IN THE COURTS

SOMETIMES RESEMBLES PROCEEDINGS BEFORE A HOUSE COMMITTEE IN THAT THE

BENEFITS AND BURDENS OF THE LEGISLATION AND ITS ALTERNATIVES HAVE TO BE

WEIGHED IN LIGHT OF THE BEST AVAILABLE INFORMATION ABOUT THE NEEDS OF

.(שם, בעמ' (582 SOCIETY AND THE NATURE OF THE PROBLEM ADDRESSED" (582

עמוד הקודם1...179180
181...316עמוד הבא