מכלול השיקולים בכגון דא העולים בבתי המשפט, נדונו בספרות המקצועית הזרה. כך דבריו של allen:
--- סוף עמוד 329 ---
Clearly, an extremely generous view of the constitutional provisions" .would severely hamper the ability of the legislature to govern Neither can every act which affects property be property cannot extend to every right or interest, even of; an economic nature .considered a deprivation of property Scope. Those limitations of the guarantees which have arisen are found nevertheless, the courts have generally advocated giving property a wide ,allen .T) "'in the interpretions of 'deprivation' or 'acquisition Commonwealth constitutions and the right not to be deprived" ; 527, 523(1993) . Comp. L. Q& . Int 42"of property (ההדגשות שלי – מ' ש') וראה גם the judiciary and:a job for the judges" ,n. K. Komesar (1988) .rev .L . Mich 86" in a massive and complex"the constitution662,.657
פרופ' hogg(קנדה) מנסח דעתו באותה רוח:
The reason that generosity should give way, rather than the stringent" making-standard of justification, concerns the policy Is wide, and the standard of justification is relaxed, role of the courts. If the scope of the guaranteed right . Then a large number of charter challenges will come before 1the courts and will fall to be determined under section Requires that the policy of the legislation 1be balanced against the policy of the charter, and since it since section Is difficult to devise meaningful standards to constrain ,laden, and even more unpredictable the balancing process, judicial review will become even more pervasive-than it is now. While some judges will welcome such even more policy Have to review the policy choices of legislative bodies, and to wasteful floods of litigation, to limit the occasions when they extensive powers, most judges will be concerned to stem the .introduce meaningful rules to the process of charter review These puposes can be accomplished only by restricting the:interpreting the charter of rights" ,hogg) " scope of charter rights . Osgood hall l. Rev 28"generosity and justification 820- 819, 817(1990)(ההדגשה שלי – מ' ש').