--- סוף עמוד 86 ---
לדופנות המאפרה - יהיו כאלה, שהעשן העולה מבדלים המושלכים אל תוך מיכל המאפרה ייאסף כולו אל חלל סגור, ומשיתקרר, יירד לתחתית המיכל ללא אפשרות יציאה החוצה. לגבי החלל עצמו נאמר בתביעה, כי מימדיו נבחרים באופן המבטיח את הקירור האמור של העשן. וכלשון התביעה (שם, בע"מ 236-237): An ash receptacle which, without the use of movable parts, retains the" characterised by the fact] ...smoke rising from objects thrown into it It consists of a closed container into which etends a shaft of[that Substantially constant cross section, the sides of which, with the sides of Beneath the shaft is provided a deflecting member... Which deflects the receptacle, form a trapped space closed above, whilst wholly ...objects thrown in wholly to one side of the lower mouth of the shaft Chosen relatively to one another and to the sides of the closed container, the dimen ions of the shaft and of the deflecting member... Being so Entirely in the trapped space, and after cooling is thrown down again that the smoke rising from objects thrown into the container is collected . Without being able during this movement to pass the lower mouth of the(ההדגשה שלי - מ' ש') "shaft גם כאן מופיעה התוצאה בתביעה עצמה.
בית המשפט דחה טענות של חוסר דיות התיאור ואי-בהירות, שנטענו נגד הפטנט.
אמר שומר המגילות, 238ord hanworth, at:
It is not an objection that the dimensions should be selected by" it seems .reference to the result, as one sees when one turns to the cases Because to me that the proportions can be ascertained without the exercise of any; new inventive faculty, if the directions laid down are followed ,the purpose of the invention is to construct a space for cooling smoke It appears to me that the proportions need and yet that is to be done within the limits of what might be called the .conventional ash receptacle Rule, if there is a field in which the proportions may vary, and yet in not be exactly laid down by the description, according to the inches of a- foot ."which success may be achieved and ensured והוסיף על כך 245lord romer, at: ...The patentee does not tell the world within what limits the relative" proportions of the integers he has mentioned must be kept to produce